The top executive team was in a lively discussion about impending budget cuts. This company cared about its workforce, and cutting $1 Million meant many jobs lost. They were coming up with creative ideas to help transition those employees who would be laid off.
Talk included exploring ways to extend healthcare coverage for their families, and an emergency fund for those who found themselves in the deepest distress. Someone suggested that the executive team members themselves take salary cuts, and after some deep thought, all agreed. After all, how could they ask their people to go through this without giving something up personally?
“Well, team,” said the president…”This has been a painful process, and it will be a difficult transition. But I want to thank each and every one of you for the sacrifices you have made in your areas of responsibility. We have our plan!”
The next week, cuts were announced, and the new budgeted plan rolled out. Many employees walked away in tears. “I wish they had included us in earlier discussions,” said one man as he walked along with his department. “At my wife’s company, they asked their employees for ideas, and each department came up with some great solutions in job-sharing and staggered leaves so that no one had to be let go. They saved 200 jobs.”
Why didn’t this man’s company leader think of the same thing? Quite simply, he held the presupposition that leaders are supposed to decide for their people, and that these people should be protected from “the ugly truth” of budget cuts until remedies were decided. Presuppositions are subtle and often hidden to those who have them. By their nature, they are almost always held subconsciously, and deeply felt.
I see this fairly regularly when I coach executive teams. A group of key executives get together to make a decision about an important issue or initiative, and the discussion is free, open, honest and engaged. But…as intelligent and caring as these decision-makers are, they usually cover only about 20% of the waterfront. This is because of the presuppositions of one or more of the leaders. These are usually based on their personal history, experiences and preferences, some or all of which may or may not be relevant to the matter under discussion. And because of these presuppositions, a whole bunch of possible solutions or actions never even reached the table.
How do you watch and avoid the effects of presuppositions? The next time you are called to make an important decision, take a few moments to reflect and write down all the presuppositions you are carrying regarding that issue. Don’t try to edit your thoughts, or to pass judgment on them. Simply write them down and take them to the meeting with you. If you will share these with your colleagues, you are guaranteed to have a much more meaningful and effective discussion as a result.
To your success!

Patti Cotton reenergizes talented leaders and their teams to achieve fulfillment and extraordinary results. For more information on how Patti Cotton can help you and your organization, click here.